Monthly Archive for March, 2008

Page 3 of 3

History suggests copyright crusade is a lost cause

History suggests copyright crusade is a lost cause (Ars Technica)

The fundamental lesson is that property rights are not—and never have been—created by Congressional fiat. Property rights emerge spontaneously from the social fabric of a community. …
If copyrights are a form of property right, then the history of American property rights provides clues about how the copyright system will need to evolve in the future. It suggests that Congress’s current strategy of imposing ever more draconian penalties for breaking laws that lack broad public support is a recipe for failure.

I couldn’t have said it better myself.

This Course Brought to You By…


This Course Brought to You By…. (Inside Higher Ed)

Here’s an interesting story about a university course with some pretty blatant corporate ties:

[The] IACC [International Anticounterfeiting Coalition] sponsor[ed] a course for which students would create a campaign against counterfeiting in which they would create a fake Web site to tell the story of a fictional student experiencing trauma because of fake consumer goods. One goal of the effort was to mislead students not in the course into thinking that they were reading about someone real.

I can almost understand how this might have seemed like a good lesson for the students of a course to learn a new marketing tactic, but it’s a bit fishy that they 1) received $10,000 from the organization, and 2) received materials to teach from. As an instructor, this is perhaps the most egregious thing–that the classroom became a pulpit for the IACC to present their view to paying students. It doesn’t sound as though critically engaging the issue of counterfeiting (or guerrilla marketing) was a part of the course at all.

Borrowed Time

Borrowed Time

Slate is running a brief montage about rebuilding public libraries, asking “What sort of public library does the “digital world” of Google, Wikipedia, and Kindle require?” This is right along track with a dialogue some of my colleagues have been having with the UW-Madison libraries as we also consider what the “library of the future” might look like. Rather than a warehouse of books, many see libraries as a re-emerging community space. I’m sympathetic to this view, but at the same time, there are elements of the library of the past that are worth keeping around:

Copenhagen, Denmark

Library at Copenhagen University